Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s
Sermon Notes 18th October on Matthew 22:15-22
by Desiree Snyman
“Give to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” This text is often used to enforce the idea that Christians should completely and unquestioningly submit to civil authority. It is also used to suggest that religion should remain exclusively religious and not interfere in politics or economics. Yet Jesus frequently talks about money, wealth and possessions. These are recurring themes in his teaching about the kingdom of God. How we earn, share and use what we have matters to our relationship with God and our neighbours. Further Jesus dies a political death at the hands of the Roman Regime. Does Jesus really mean that we should give unquestioning obedience to whatever authority governs us? Does he mean that there should be a complete separation between our spiritual lives and the political and economic realities of our world?
A dangerous question
When we step into the scene in Matthew's Gospel, we find ourselves in the middle of an ongoing conflict between Jesus and various factions within Judaism. Usually, the tensions between these factions were considerable. Here we have an unlikely alliance between the Herodians and the Pharisees. As the saying goes, the enemy of my enemy is my friend.
The Herodians supported the ruling dynasty of Herod, whose power depended upon Rome. If we want a flavour of the world of Herodian politics, we might remember the banquet where a ruler's reckless promise results in John the Baptist's head being presented on a platter.
The Pharisees, on the other hand, get a particularly bad rap in Christian circles, yet they were more progressive and lenient than other factions, such as the Essenes. They were lay religious teachers who sought to make Jewish faith and practice part of everyday life. Some scholars understand Jesus himself as having much in common with the Pharisees and that he himself was a pharisee (e.g. Amy-Jill Levine).
These very different factions now unite in an attempt to discredit and ambush Jesus. They don't come themselves. They send their disciples. The question they ask is whether or not taxes should be paid to Caesar. This is a loaded question with terrifying implications.
Remember that the Gospel of Matthew is written in the first century and considers events such as the First Jewish–Roman War (66–73/74 CE). It reflects the aftermath of that conflict, particularly Rome’s destruction of Jerusalem and its Temple in 70 CE. In 6 CE, Judea came under direct Roman administration, and Quirinius conducted a census for taxation. This provoked resistance led by Judas the Galilean. The imperial tax in Matthew 22:15–22 therefore carried the weight of Roman occupation and subjection. Rome generated enormous wealth through the taxation of conquered peoples. Understandably, there was considerable resentment. Resistance to Roman taxation was also connected with the possibility of revolt. Refusing to pay tribute could be understood as a challenge to Roman authority, and Rome's response to rebellion could be swift and deadly.
What the questioners are really asking Jesus is whether he is prepared to challenge Rome, with all the consequences that might follow. They are asking Jesus to admit a declaration of war. This is not simply an ancient question for an ancient people. It echoes through the centuries to our own time. Do we purchase oil or gas from Russia, knowing that the proceeds may help fund an unjust war? How do our economic choices sustain systems of violence and oppression? These are deeply political, economic and spiritual questions.
Whose image is on the coin?
Notice how Jesus responds. He asks them to produce a denarius, the coin used to pay the tax. Notice that Jesus does not produce the coin himself. They do. In this moment, Jesus exposes something about the people asking the question. Jesus reveals it as their question, not his. Jesus asks whose image is stamped upon the coin. It is the image of Tiberius Caesar, the Roman emperor. Then comes that remarkable response: “Give to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's.” There are two directions in which we might take this. The first is to ask: What do we owe God?
The whole premise of Jewish spirituality is expressed in the words of the psalmist: “The earth is the Lord's and all that is in it.” Everything belongs to God. If we wish to give to God the things that are God's, we owe God everything. There is another question. Gazing at the image of Caesar stamped upon the coin, we might ask: Whose image is stamped upon us? We are stamped with the image of God – the Imago Dei. This takes us back to Genesis.
In Genesis 2 the Creator takes earth or mud, adamah, from which the creator makes an adam, earthling, or my preferred term a “mud clod”. Creator then breathes Divine Breath into the mud clod, and it begins to live. We are mud creatures with divine breath within us. At the heart of being human is this paradox of being earth and Divine Breath at the same time. We are fragile and vulnerable and dense like mud. Yet we have a capacity for God, we reach towards infinity. God's presence flows through us and through every human being. Being human is this double experience. We are fragile and vulnerable. The many selves we carry through life are not wrong, but they are easily hurt and often afraid. Yet at the core of who we are is something profoundly sacred. We can say with the psalmist: “I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made.” The fragile mud of our humanity is as much part of God's beloved creation as the divine breath that gives us life. Both are holy.
Give to God what is God's
The coin bears the image of Caesar. We bear the image of God. To give to God the things that are God's is to offer our very selves, our very being, our very breath. Caesar may stamp his image upon a coin, but Caesar does not own the people who bear God's image. Jesus is not asking us to divide our lives into two separate compartments, one belonging to Caesar and the other to God. Jesus is inviting us to recognise that our whole lives belong to God: our fragile humanity, our gifts, our relationships, our choices, our money, our politics, our very breath. To give to God the things that are God's is to give nothing less than ourselves. Every breath. Every moment. Every act of love.