Where do we look for God?
Sermon Notes 11th October on Matthew 22:1-14
by Desiree Snyman
People often think that the answer to any riddle posed in church is Jesus. In much the same way, when we hear a parable about a king, we assume that the king must represent God. Sometimes a king is just a king. In the words of Monty Python’s Life of Brian: “He’s not the Messiah. He’s a very naughty boy!”
Instead of beginning with theology and Scripture, let us begin with experience, especially the experiences of people who live on the margins of society because of poverty, injustice or systemic violence.
Hearing the story through different eyes.
I invite you to think of someone whose story you may have encountered who lives life on the margins of society, whose life has been shaped by poverty, injustice, trauma or violence. This could be any story you have encountered either personally or on the news or through books or films. A refugee escaping the Taliban, forced to leave a beloved homeland. A young mother fleeing domestic violence. Someone who has been imprisoned or persecuted for challenging an unjust regime. Remember the textures of their stories. Remember also their courage and resilience in transforming themselves and those around them. How might they hear the story before us today? Which character might they identify with? Where might they recognise the God described by Jesus, who says come to me all you who labour and are heavy laden and I will give you rest. Where might they recognise Woman Wisdom, who prepares a feast and invites people into life?
A feast or a banquet?
A shared meal is an image Jesus often uses to describe a new creation, a new reality in the kingdom of God. Jesus draws on a rich biblical tradition, including the figure of Woman Wisdom in Proverbs 9, who prepares a feast and invites people to come and eat. This is an image of abundance and belonging. Examples include the feeding of the more than 5000 with bread and fish and the Last Supper.
There is another kind of banquet in the Gospels. Remember the banquet of Herod, a banquet of political intrigue, where a dance and a ruler’s reckless promise end with John the Baptist’s head being brought in on a platter. This is a banquet where power and violence determine who lives and who dies.
What is before us today? The feast of belonging or Herod’s banquet of death?
The spiral of violence
Through the eyes of those who have experienced injustice or trauma, we encounter a king who invites people to a banquet. An authoritarian ruler. A brutal tyrant. Someone whose power cannot safely be challenged. Perhaps he reminds them of Herod, a violent partner, or the Taliban who caused them to flee a beloved homeland.
The invited guests refuse to come. Some seize and kill the king’s messengers. The spiral of violence does its worst. The king sends his troops to destroy those who oppose him and burns their city.
When others are invited, people respond. Do they come because they want to be there? Or because the alternative is the wrath and retaliation of the king? The good and the bad alike are gathered at the banquet. Some may benefit from their association with the king. Others may be there simply because that is the reality of living under such power.
Living within systems of power
I admit that I recognise something of this feeling. I may have a sincere desire to live fully in harmony with the earth. The reality is that I drove here in a diesel car. We will go home and eat food stored in plastic. I grew up at the height of apartheid and was indoctrinated into this system of oppression. I was a child, yet I benefitted from the oppression of others.
Many of us want to participate in a better world, but we remain caught within systems that make this difficult. Yet it reminds us that recognising something as wrong does not necessarily mean we can simply remove ourselves from it.
Sometimes people comply because they are afraid. Sometimes because they see no alternative. Sometimes because they have become so accustomed to the way things are that they no longer question them. Sometimes people resist. One such person may be present at the banquet.
The guest without a wedding garment
We are not told why one guest doesn’t have the wedding garment. Perhaps his clothing becomes a quiet act of resistance against the injustice of the king.
What if, in a room filled with people who have submitted to the king's demands, this one person stands apart?
The king confronts him. He remains silent. The king orders that he be bound and thrown into the outer darkness, where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth. There is something familiar about this story.
Jesus, too, is arrested and bound. Jesus, too, stands before those who exercise power. Jesus, too, remains silent before his accusers. Jesus, too, is taken outside the city, where he is crucified.
What if we have been looking for Jesus in the wrong place? What if Jesus is represented by the person who is rejected because he refuses to conform?
This is one possible reading, and it challenges the more familiar interpretation of the parable.
The outer darkness
We usually understand the outer darkness as a place of divine punishment. Matthew does use this language elsewhere as an image of judgement. What if, in this reading, the outer darkness is where those rejected by the powerful find themselves? What if it is the place where we encounter those who have been excluded, silenced and cast aside?
The language of weeping and gnashing of teeth might then remind us of the suffering and anger of those who experience injustice. It is not that suffering or exclusion is itself a blessing. Rather, it is among those who suffer that Jesus calls us to recognise the presence of God.
Remember the Beatitudes. Blessed are the poor in spirit. Blessed are those who mourn. Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness. Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness' sake. Jesus turns our expectations upside down. Later, in Matthew 25, Jesus identifies himself with the hungry, the thirsty, the stranger, the naked, the sick and the imprisoned. The outer darkness becomes a place where we are invited to stand in solidarity with the oppressed, because God does not abandon those whom the powerful cast out.
Whose table do we choose?
The question is not simply whether we have accepted the king's invitation. We ask whose table we are sitting at. Is it the banquet of domination, where people participate because they fear the consequences of refusing? Or is it the feast of Woman Wisdom, where people are invited into life?
The kingdom of God is not simply another version of the kingdoms we already know. Jesus invites us to imagine a different reality. A world where power is not exercised through violence, where belonging is not dependent on conformity, and where those who have been pushed to the margins are brought into the centre.
One question this parable leaves us with is this: Why are we so quick to recognise God in the person who exercises power, rather than in the person who suffers under it?